2Fin vs Firefly III

AI2Fin vs Firefly III

Firefly III is the benchmark for keeping your finances on your own hardware and your books in strict double-entry. 2Fin runs on your machine too — but it arrives as an app rather than a server you administer, and it categorises for you instead of waiting for you to write every rule first.

Where AI2Fin takes a different approach

Built differently where it counts — here is how.

Local-first without running a server

Firefly III keeps your data private by making you host it: Docker, a database, updates, backups, a proxy. 2Fin desktop puts the same data on the same machine and asks none of that — it takes a checked copy of your records daily, keeps about a month of them beside your data, and restores from one by itself if the file is ever damaged. An outbound record inside the app lists every request that left, so it is a claim you check rather than take on trust.

Categorisation that works from the first import

Firefly III categorises what its rules tell it to, which means a blank slate until you have written them. 2Fin categorises immediately and learns from every correction — and still gives you a rule engine underneath for what you want pinned exactly.

Built for tax, not only for tracking

Firefly III tracks where money went. 2Fin also works out what it means at tax time, in whichever country you file — GST, VAT and BAS treatment, deductions surfaced through the year, and filing exports. 2Fin helps you find and organise potential deductions; always confirm eligibility with your accountant or tax authority.

Ask a question instead of building a report

Both give you charts. 2Fin also answers in words: ask what you spent on fuel last quarter against the one before, and get the number without assembling a report to find it.

The same situation, in both

A $1,650 laptop for work

You buy a $1,650 laptop on your card and use it about 80% for work.

In Firefly III

You record the withdrawal into an expense account you set up, and the rule that files the next one is yours to write; the tax side — what is claimable and over how long — is yours to work out.

In 2Fin

The card transaction is categorised as it arrives, with its GST or VAT split out, and goes into the asset register with an 80% business share, so the depreciation schedule follows the rules of the country you file in.

Feature by feature

Feature
2Fin
Firefly III
Runs on your own machine
Yes — desktop app, no server to run
Yes — you host and maintain it
Setup
Install and open; backups run themselves
Docker, database, updates, backups
Double-entry ledger
Single-entry to use, balanced double-entry journal on export
Yes, throughout
Rule engine
Yes — contains, equals, starts-with, regex, amount and merchant matching, in priority order
Yes, extensive
Budgets and savings goals
Yes — limits, progress bars, savings goals
Yes — budgets and piggy banks
Automatic categorisation
Yes, and learns from your corrections
Rules you write yourself
Receipt capture
Photograph it — total, merchant and date are read and matched
Attach files manually
Conversational questions
Yes
No
Tax treatment and filing exports
Yes, country-aware
No
Cost
Free plan; paid tiers add tax and reporting
Free software; you pay for hosting

Firefly III is free, open-source software — the cost is hosting it. 2Fin starts free, with tax treatment, reporting and filing exports on Premium (US$23/month).

Based on publicly available information. Competitor features and pricing may change — verify directly.

Which one fits you?

Both are good tools — the right pick depends on what your business needs most.

Firefly III suits you when…

  • You want strict double-entry, with every movement balanced across asset, expense and revenue accounts.
  • You enjoy running your own infrastructure and want full control of the database and upgrade schedule.
  • You track many accounts, wallets and currencies by hand and want a ledger built for exactly that.
  • You would rather write every rule yourself than have anything categorised on your behalf.

2Fin suits you when…

  • You want your data on your own machine but not a server to administer.
  • You want categorisation working from the first import, not after an evening of rule-writing.
  • Tax matters to you — GST, VAT or sales tax for 88 countries, income-tax estimates in five, deductions and filing exports, rather than tracking alone.
  • You would rather ask a question than build a report to answer it.
Your data can stay on your machineVerify it yourself →

AI2Fin pricing and plans

2Fin is free to start. Premium is US$23 a month (US$222 a year), ELITE+ is US$42 a month (US$432 a year) and AUTO+ is US$54 a month (US$555 a year), billed in US dollars.

Hover, tap or tab to any underlined feature to learn more.

MonthlyAnnual Save up to 20%

FREE

Free
No card, no time limit

For getting every record in one place, at no cost.

Included

  • Capture
  • Organise
  • Automate
  • Share
Get 2Fin free (opens in a new tab)
Most Popular

PREMIUM

US$23
USD / month

For employees and sole traders who want every deduction found and the busywork done.

Everything in Free, plus

  • Capture
  • Organise
  • Tax
  • Automate
Start Premium (opens in a new tab)
Best Value

ELITE+

US$42
USD / month

For businesses and accountants who lodge, report and keep the books.

Everything in Premium, plus

  • Organise
  • Tax
  • Automate
  • ShareGoogle SheetsMicrosoft ExcelNotionAirtable
Start ELITE+ (opens in a new tab)
Most Automated

AUTO+

US$54
USD / month

For owners who want receipts and reports to arrive on their own.

Everything in ELITE+, plus

  • Capture
  • Automate
Start AUTO+ (opens in a new tab)

Swipe to see every plan

Compare all features

Every 2Fin plan side by side, grouped by what you do
What each 2Fin plan includes
FeatureFREEUS$0PREMIUMUS$23 / monthELITE+US$42 / monthAUTO+US$54 / month
Capture
Statement uploads into bucketsCSV, Excel or PDF. On the free desktop app, statements come in through the CSV import insteadIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Live feeds from your own sheet or bank-feed accountA Google Sheet, or a provider account you hold such as SimpleFIN or BankSyncIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Photo and PDF receipts, read and matchedRead in the language they are printed inNot includedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Forward receipts by emailNot includedNot includedNot includedIncluded
Organise
Transactions, categories and bills in one placeIncluding recurring paymentsIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Upcoming bills, pay days and money you are owedPayments matched to what you are owed as they landIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Budgets against what you actually spentIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Travel and vehicle tripsIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Properties: what each one really costsRented, business and private partsIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Automatic categoriesNot includedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Your own categorising rulesNot includedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Spending and bills analyticsNot includedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Views by project, client or tax purposeCalled Lenses in the app; the Properties lens is built in on every planNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
Tax
Tax analysis that knows your situationNot includedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Tax exports, including ATO myDeductionsNot includedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Tax reports and summariesNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
BAS, VAT and GST statementsNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
Asset register, depreciation, profit & loss and TPARNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
Property write-offs and scheduleDepreciation, capital works, a schedule for your accountantNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
Automate
Ask Fin about your money25 messages a monthUnlimitedUnlimitedUnlimited
Fin reads the files you uploadNot includedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Fin, your assistant, with its own workspaceNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
Your week in review, on the dashboardIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Signed webhooks for Zapier, Make and n8nNot includedNot includedNot includedIncluded
Reports emailed on the schedule you setNot includedNot includedNot includedIncluded
Share
Push to Google Sheets, Excel, Notion or AirtableBank-feed transactions includedNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
Send transactions to Xero or QuickBooks OnlineCoded, with the receipt attachedNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
Practice workspace for accountantsYour clients can be on any planNot includedNot includedIncludedIncluded
Connect Claude or ChatGPT, with the access you approveWhat they can read follows your planIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded
Desktop app, with your data on your machineIncludedIncludedIncludedIncluded

ENTERPRISE

Custom

Enterprise-grade data control is the default here — on every plan.

Your records can stay on your own machine or in your own cloud, telemetry stays off unless you turn it on, and Fin keeps an auditable record of everything it sends. Enterprise adds the people and the paperwork: dedicated support, custom deployment and reviews for large-scale operations.

Verify it yourself
  • AES-256 encryption
  • GDPR-aligned
  • Cancel anytime
  • ATO-ready exports
  • Setup in 5 minutes
Learn more about our security stance

AI2Fin vs Firefly III — common questions

Does 2Fin do double-entry bookkeeping?

Not as the way you ENTER things, and deliberately so — Firefly III asks you to think in debits and credits, which is more machinery than most sole traders want when they are photographing a receipt. 2Fin records transactions the way a bank statement reads. But it exports a real double-entry journal: every transaction expands to a balanced entry naming both accounts, with GST split into its own account, and total debits equal total credits. Single-entry to use, double-entry to hand over.

Does 2Fin have a rule engine like Firefly III?

Yes. Match on description, merchant or amount using contains, equals, starts-with, regex and numeric comparisons, and order rules by priority so the specific ones win. The difference is that 2Fin also categorises with no rules at all and learns from your corrections, so the rule engine is for what you want pinned exactly rather than for everything.

Is 2Fin as private as self-hosting Firefly III?

On the desktop app your records, receipts and database are files in a folder you own, and the free plan has no account to create. The app shows an outbound record of every request that left, and a Sovereign setting stops all of it. Self-hosting Firefly III gives you the same data locality; 2Fin gets there without asking you to run and secure a server.

Does 2Fin have budgets and savings goals?

Yes. You set a spending limit per category before the period starts, each one shows a progress bar that turns amber at 80 per cent and red at 100, and a drift strip lists the categories running ahead of pace so you see them the moment you open the page. Savings goals hold a running balance towards a target and are topped up in priority order, with one press, from whatever income is left once your limits are covered — Firefly III calls those piggy banks; the idea is the same. You can also cap a whole set of categories at once rather than one at a time.

Can I move from Firefly III to 2Fin?

Yes. Export your transactions to CSV and import them — 2Fin maps the columns for you and handles multiple currencies. You can also keep a spreadsheet as a live source and it will stay in step as rows are added.

See the difference for yourself

Free plan, no card needed. Start in seconds.

Get 2Fin free →

See all comparisons, or explore free tax tools.